1. Fred Morath (Charter)
2. Ed Morath (Charter)
3. Willis R. Magee (Charter)
4. Harry Standley (Charter) 
5. Fred Barr (Charter)
6. Carl Blaurock (1923)
7. John Garrett (1924)
8. William Ervin (1925)
9. George McDonald (1926)
10. George Harvey (1927)
11. William Penland (1928)
12. Robert Ormes (1929)
14.
Chuck Cogan (1931)
15.
Francis Froelicher (1932)
16.
Joe Rohrer (1933)
17.
Charles Brown (1934)
18.
Harvey Sethman (1935)
19.
Julius Jones (1936)
20.
John Graham (1937)
21.
Earl Ewing (1938)
22.
Joseph Graham (1939)
23.
Don Lawrie (1940)
24.
Herbert Hollister (1941)
(1942)
25.
Carl Melzer (1943)
26.
Don Obee (1944)
27.
Dwight Hamilton (1945)
28.
Vernon Twombly (1946)
29.
Stanley Boucher (1947)
30.
Standley Balcomb (1948)
31.
Jack McDowell (1949)
32.
John Alexander (1950)
33.
Roy Rickus (1951)
34.
H.M. Towles (1952)
35.
Robert Ellingwood (1953)
36.
Jim Bates (1954)
37.
Robert Watson (1955)
38.
Sam Colt (1956)
39.
Gene Novell (1957)
40.
Lyman Blakeman (1958)
41.
Art Kaphen (1959)
42.
Ben Kriegh (1960)
43.
George Lindeman (1961)
44.
Ed Kirches (1962)
45.
Bruce Sommers (1963)
46.
Ed Wallick (1964)
47.
Wilbur Arnold (1965)
48.
Scotty Kenton (1966)
49.
Al Pierce (1967)
50.
Arne Magnus (1968)
51.
Tom Rorabaugh (1969)
52.
Bob Stafford (1970)
53.
Jack Roeser (1971)
54.
Ed Calvert (1972)
55.
Ted Lindeman (1973)
56.
Ken Geddes (1974)
57.
Gordon Bates (1975)
58.
Bill Lloyd (1976)
59.
John Graham (1977)
60.
Daryl Hickey (1978)
61.
Tom Kennedy (1979)
62.
Mike Graham (1980)
63.
Carl Lindeman (1981)
64.
Jeff Williams (1982)
65.
Bill Lindeman (1983)
66.
Frank Brunk (1984)
67.
Ryer Hitchcock (1985)
68.
Bill Willhoit (1986)
69.
Dave Kosley (1987)
70.
Bob Sommers (1988)
71.
Charles Bowles (1989)
72.
Mike Reeder (1990)
73.
Rick Trojanovich (1991)
74.
Philip Stafford (1992)
75.
Philip Pierce (1993)
76.
Paul Bjork (1994)
77.
Mike Boggs (1995)
78.
Glen Law (1996)
79.
Sue Graham (1997)
80.
Tim Stafford (1998)
81.
Jack Donley (1999)
82.
Dan Stuart (2000)
83.
Sean O'Donnell (2001)
84.
Cliff Donnelly (2002)
85.
Donald Sanborn (2003)
86.
Cindy Bowles (2004)
87.
David Hunting (2005)
88.
Patrick Naughton (2006)
89.
Mark Szabo (2007)
90.
Chuck Fogleman (2008)
91.
Bill Slaughter (2009)
92.
Bill Lahman (2010))
93.
Ann Nichols (2011)
94.
Wally Wininger (2012)
95.
Nick Baki (2013)
96.
Mark Copelin (2014)
97.
Scott Smetana (2015)
98.
Brooke Chesnut (2016)
99.
David Artusi (2017)
100.
Lance Stark (2018)
101.
Tyler Stuart (2019)
102.
Thomas Lear (2020)
103.
Priscilla Clayton (2021)
104.
Chris Mattingly (2022)
105.
Britt Jones (2023)
106.
Luke Stark (2024 posthumously)
107.
Rachael Stark (2024)
- Two members selected and neither wanted to be number 13.